Shop Now

Fear of missing out?

Get our bi-monthly email for exclusive coupon codes, news & other good stuff!

Shop Now

Fear of missing out?

Get our bi-monthly email for exclusive coupon codes, news & other good stuff!

Consigning With Us

Updated: December 5

Important Note: We update this list every few days. Please check it the day you’re planning to come in and ensure you’re only bringing what is currently on the list. We have dozens of people trying to drop-off hundreds of items a week. We do not have the time, resources, or space to accommodate this.  And the below list is all we have room for and want.

Also, please review drop-off times & policy below. By dropping off items with us, it is assumed you have read and agree to the terms outlined on this page. Thanks!


Clothing & Accessories

  • MimiTen mittens / Kombi long-style mittens
  • Skidoo-style mittens & gloves
  • MEC toaster mitts & gloves
  • Merlin’s Magic Sleepsuits
  • MEC Toaster suits
  • HBC items: sleepers, hats, socks, sweaters
  • Band Tshirts & onesies
  • New in packaging socks / New in packaging underwear & training pants


  • BOGS winter boots – New & Like-new condition
  • Sorel boots – New & Like-new condition
  • Padraigs! Padraigs! Padraigs!

Toys & Books

  • New in box toys, “giftable” for the holidays
  • Manhattan toys: Swishes & Winkels & Beads
  • Schleich animals & figures
  • Vintage & reproduction Fisher Price toys (Record players, Happy Apples, etc.)
  • American Girl dolls and clothing
  • Corolle dolls, clothing, accessories
  • Big Sister / Big Brother books
  • Complete book sets: Harry Potter / Chronicles of Narnia
  • Book: The Secret World of Og, Pierre Berton
  • Book: The Book with No Pictures, B.J. Novak
  • Book: DADA, Jimmy Fallon
  • Books & CDs: Go the F#*k to Sleep / You Have to F#*king Eat

Gear & Nursery

  • EZPZ placements
  • Phil & Ted lobster chairs
  • Bunnykins & Wedgwood: Piggybanks only
  • Dock A Tots, Prisitne condition
  • ERGO 360 carriers
  • Baby Bjorn carriers
  • Front carrier covers (Bjorn, Jolly Jumper, etc.)
  • Didymos wraps & similar high-end
  • Stroller cup holders / Toddler trays / Caddies / Mommy Hooks
  • High-end, pristine umbrella strollers (i.e. UppaBaby G-luxe, MacLaren)
  • Airplane travel slings
  • Stroller piggy-back boards
  • HBC, Canadiana & Toronto/Local-themed items
  • GRO clocks & Thermometers
  • Restoration Hardware items

Maternity & Nursing:

  • Make-My-Belly-Fit maternity coat extenders & similar


If you’d like to consign with us or have an account and would like to drop off more, please read the below.

  • Our consignment ratio is 65% for Merrily, merrily & 35% for consignors, as of February 1, 2017. All items listed before this time will be honoured at the previously agreed upon ratio. This only affects new items dropped off after February 1. 
  • Consignor profit can be used as cash or credit (Same value)
  • To set-up an account, we require a minimum of 10 items or a value of $50+
  • Items must stay at least 6 months due to the time invested preparing them for sale

Where & when do I drop off my items? Please bring them to our store at 1854 Danforth Avenue during these hours: Wednesday – Friday, 11-5 / Sunday, 12-3.

How is my account set-up? We inventory everything in an itemized list that shows the items & their associated prices. Your account is assigned a unique number and each item is catalogued and tracked in our system daily.

What & how do I get paid for my items? You receive 50/40/35% of the purchase price, upon sale, depending on when your items were dropped off.  Prices are based on the original price, condition, seasonality, and a fair price for our customers. The money you make as people buy your items accumulates in your account. You can make a purchase from your account anytime, be paid by cash, cheque, or email transfer (EMT). Please note there is a $1.50 charge for an EMT.

How do I bring my items in? Please ensure items are laundered and free of imperfections (rips, stains, markered labels, name labels, broken zippers, pet hair, pilling, dirt in shoe treads, etc.) and have all parts & working batteries. If you wouldn’t buy it in a store, please do not bring it in. Also, snapping snaps, buttoning buttons and removing name labels is appreciated.  If items have ‘too much love’ on them, we won’t list them. We reserve the right to donate / dispose of an accepted item without notice if there are any defects and to reduce the price of items based on annual sales. If there are items we can’t take you may keep them or have us donate them on your behalf. Please pick these items up within one week, if you would like them back.

When will my items be on the site? We endeavour to get your things online for sale quickly. Sometimes if we get a lot at once or your drop-off is large, it may take a few weeks to get everything inventoried, photographed, and uploaded to the site.

Can I take items back? / How do I close my account? Reviewing, prepping, cataloguing, photographing, and the overall management of your account is very time consuming. For this reason, we ask that you leave your items with us for at least 6 months. We do not get rid of items after 6 months. They can stay until they sell! If you elect to take items back or close your account, we ask that you pick your items up within 1 week, please. If your account is inactive for 1 year (We don’t see or hear from you), it will be automatically closed.

How do I know how much is in my account? Currently, there is no automated way to check your account balance. Please send us a note or pop into the store and we’ll let you know.

I make awesome things. How do I sell them with you? Please get in touch and let’s talk!


Clothing & Linens

What we take is at our discretion based on our personal tastes and the known tastes of our customers. We especially like handmade items, organic pieces, boutique treasures & import brands. All clothing must be:

  • Newborn – Children’s 16 sizes
  • Freshly laundered & wrinkle-free
  • Free of defects (stains, tears, visible wear, pilling, fading, etc.)
  • Seasonally-appropriate


Shoes need to be in new or like-new condition. If they are a high end brand like Livie & Luca, Tip Toey Joey, Pediped, etc. some slight wear condition may be considered. Walking shoes, leather shoes, high-end sneakers and imports sell really well. We’re always looking for Padraigs, cool kicks, Robeez, moccasins, and high-end walking shoes.

Toys, Books, Music & DVDs

We delight in finding interesting items that can’t be found elsewhere. Do you have homemade wooden toys or vintage children’s books lying around? Bring them in and let us take a look! Also, we happily accept French and other language items.

Equipment & Gear

We sell a variety of equipment and children’s safety is our number one priority. We’re looking for big and small items –both practical and whimsical. Some of the categories we’re always looking for include sleep sacks, feeding accessories, diaper bags, and carriers & wraps.


Due to space constraints, our intake of furniture is limited to the highest quality and most interesting items. Have an amazing crib or a beautiful rug that your little one has outgrown? Bring it in and let us take a look. Or, if your items are too big to bring in, please feel free to send us pictures and descriptions. We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Handmade Items

We’re thrilled to get handmade items of all descriptions. If you want to sell your wares with us, we would LOVE to hear from you. Please get in touch!

Items we never accept:

  • Items on manufacturer recall lists
  • Safety items / hardware
  • Life jackets & floatation vests
  • Drop-side cribs
  • Items with missing pieces / components
  • Used socks & underwear
  • Pekkle snap sleepers
  • Bumper pads that are not the breathable/mesh variety
  • Clothing with toggles or drawstrings longer than 7cm
  • Items with tag labelling, missing buttons, fading, pilling, tears, rips, stains, imperfections of any kind!
  • Toys without batteries
  • Inflatable toys or equipment
  • VHS tapes & audio cassettes
  • Used stuffed animals (new, vintage & handmade accepted)
  • Unsealed puzzles over 50 pieces
  • Older versions of Leapfrog systems & media
  • Car seats & car booster seats
  • Bath seats with suction cups
  • Walkers
  • Seat belt adjusters
  • Most sports equipment / Ski equipment
  • Breast pumps, breast pump accessories, etc. (Motors & sealed in package accepted)
  • Clothes that were great for pregnancy but aren’t a maternity piece
  • Small Adult clothing

If you’re unsure about a specific item, please get in touch!